Vitalik Buterin on why cross-chain bridges will not be a part of the multi-chain future – CryptoSlate

Advertisements

In a well-publicized tweet last week, Vitalik Buterin spoke out against the use of cross-chain solutions by Ethereum and other blockchains in favor of a multi-chain future.

My argument for why the future will be *multi-chain* but not *cross-chain*: There are fundamental limits to the security of bridges hopping across multiple “zones of sovereignty”. Retrieved from https://t.co/3g1GUvuA3A: pic.twitter.com/tEYz8vb59b

— vitalik.eth (@VitalikButerin) January 7, 2022

For Buterin, cross-chain bridges aren’t ideal because they increase security risks when transferring assets. This security trade-off occurs because the assets’ attack vectors are increased across a larger network surface as they move across an increasing number of chains and decentralized applications with different security principles.

If your ETH is contained in Ethereum, it only depends on the security validation of the Ethereum network. But when moving ETH across different chains on cross-chain bridges, the security of ETH now depends not only on Ethereum, but also on the security verification of the target chain and all other cross-chain solutions used for transferring, packaging and locking be used to increase wealth.

Buterin put it in a nutshell in his tweet:

“Now imagine what happens when you move 100 ETH to a bridge on Solana to get 100 Solana WETH and then Ethereum is 51% attacked. The attacker deposited a pile of his own ETH with Solana-WETH and then reversed that transaction on the Ethereum side once the Solana side confirmed it. The Solana WETH contract is now not fully hedged and maybe your 100 Solana WETH is now only worth 60 ETH. Even if there is a perfect ZK-SNARK based bridge that fully validates the consensus, it is still vulnerable to theft from 51% of such attacks.”

The distribution of assets across different blockchain security networks also means that chains become more interdependent as the same assets are collateralized and used for different purposes. This increased risk of contagion could lead to a domino effect that would ripple through different blockchain ecosystems if one suffered an attack, as opposed to if the asset remained on a blockchain:

“The problem gets worse when you go beyond two chains. If there are 100 chains, then you will end up with dapps with many dependencies between those chains, and 51% attacking even one chain would create a systemic contagion that threatens the economy of the entire ecosystem.”

Additional security risks with cross-chain bridges

Buterin highlights a key security issue of cross-chain bridges, but the risks don’t stop there. The vast majority of cross-chain bridges today typically facilitate asset transfers through centralized federations and external validators.

These solutions bypass the tedious and expensive process of decentralized chain validation, making transactions cheaper and faster. Popular examples include BitGo’s Wrapped Bitcoin (WBTC), Axie Infinity’s Ronin Bridge, Terra’s Shuttle Bridge, and more.

However, this also means that transactions are moving away from a trusted form of verification, increasing the reliance on the cross-chain bridge operator rather than the decentralized security of the underlying blockchain network.

In short, the main risks of cross-chain solutions can be summarized in two points. First, cross-chain solutions increase the number of attack vectors for the crypto assets and increase the risk of contagion across chains. Second, the transferred assets are routed through a variety of external validation networks that may no longer remain decentralized and trusted, increasing risk via the same attack vectors.

Users will lose *so much* money in cross-chain bridges over the next year. pic.twitter.com/d0nntkpde7

— Dmitriy Berenzon (@dberenzon) August 27, 2021

The multi-chain future

Cross-chain bridges remain popular with users for the simple reason that they offer a premium in terms of speed and low cost. It’s a temporary band-aid for a bigger problem. But as with all patches, they must be removed.

Kadan Stadelmann, CTO of Komodo, agrees with Buterin that this security risk will gradually raise awareness and accelerate crypto’s journey into the multi-chain future:

“In the future, we will have both multi-chain ecosystem networks like Polkadot and Cosmos, where chains rely on a common security mechanism, and cross-chain bridges like AtomicDEX, connecting blockchain ecosystems that would otherwise be isolated. This will likely mean that DEXs and bridge solutions will achieve mass adoption.”

Multi-chain ecosystems (sometimes referred to as Layer 0 chains) like Cosmos and Polkadot were designed to avoid the security issues of cross-chain bridges. The Polkadot blockchain allows Dapp developers to set up their own custom blockchains (dubbed “parachains”) on top of it. All parachains are interconnected through Polkadot’s main relay chain hub, which serves to coordinate security and asset transfers across all of its parachains.

Polkadot’s Shared Security Federation model (source)

The concept is similar for Cosmos, which consists of an ecosystem of multiple independent Cosmos chains (called zones) that can send tokens and data to each other. However, unlike Polkadot, there are multiple central hubs that zones can plug into to reach other zones. Crypto.com’s Terra, THORChain, and Cronos chain are among the most popular names to take up residence on Cosmos.

The Cosmos Hub & Spoke model is the internet of blockchains (Source: https://v1.cosmos.network/intro)Cosmos’ Hub & Spoke Model is the Internet of Blockchains (source)

Both Polkadot and Cosmos strive to achieve asset interoperability while ensuring trusted transfer of assets where users do not have to rely on intermediary entities such as cross-chain solutions.

CryptoSlate Newsletter

Featuring a roundup of the top daily stories in the world of crypto, DeFi, NFTs and more.

Get one edge in the cryptoasset market

Access more crypto insights and context in each article as a paying member of CryptoSlate Edge.

On-chain analysis

Price Snapshots

More context

Sign up now for $19/month. Discover all the advantages


Share post on

Sonic BTC is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Polkadot

Top 10 Cryptocurrencies With a Better Future Than Bitcoin – hackernoon.com

Cryptocurrencies gaining popularity due to their ability to provide smooth transaction payments in a...

By wpadminsonic164
Meghan Markle’s Summer Shorts Are The Chic Way To Go Short – STYLECASTER Polkadot

Meghan Markle’s Summer Shorts Are The Chic Way To Go Short – STYLECASTER

Scroll To See More Images If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service...

By wpadminsonic164
Bullish cryptos of the month: Calyx Token (CLX), Polkadot (DOT), and NEAR Protocol (NEAR) – Crypto Mode Polkadot

Bullish cryptos of the month: Calyx Token (CLX), Polkadot (DOT), and NEAR Protocol (NEAR) – Crypto Mode

With the global cryptocurrency market rebounding after a difficult period, it's only right to...

By wpadminsonic164
Polkadot

Ruler Harry and Meghan Markle kiss at polo match in uncommon PDA second – Page Six

Whoa Nelly! Prince Harry and Meghan Markle showed rare PDA Sunday as they kissed...

By wpadminsonic164
Cannes 2022: Deepika Padukone Flaunts Her Million-Dollar Smile In Green Polka-Dot Outfit – News18 Polkadot

Cannes 2022: Deepika Padukone Flaunts Her Million-Dollar Smile In Green Polka-Dot Outfit – News18

Bollywood actress Deepika Padukone is currently at the Cannes Film Festival and with each...

By wpadminsonic164
Efinity wins Polkadot’s sixth Parachain public sale – CryptoSlate Polkadot

Efinity wins Polkadot’s sixth Parachain public sale – CryptoSlate

Efinity joins the League of. at Speckle Parachain slot auction winners - Acala, Moonbeam,...

By wpadminsonic164
Can Logarithmic Finance (LOG) Repeat the 4000% Positive aspects of The Sandbox (SAND) and Compete with Polkadot (DOT)?  – www.crowdwisdom.reside Polkadot

Can Logarithmic Finance (LOG) Repeat the 4000% Positive aspects of The Sandbox (SAND) and Compete with Polkadot (DOT)? – www.crowdwisdom.reside

This is a sponsored advertising post. Nothing in this content should be construed as...

By wpadminsonic164
Harry Styles CBeebies Bedtime Stories: First pictures from episode – Metro.co.uk Polkadot

Harry Styles CBeebies Bedtime Stories: First pictures from episode – Metro.co.uk

Harry Styles will be reading In Every House, On Every Street (Picture: PA)CBeebies has...

By wpadminsonic164

Latest Posts

Could Calyx Token (CLX) be essentially as fruitful as major cryptos like Cardano (ADA) and Ripple (XRP)? – ANI News Cardano

Could Calyx Token (CLX) be essentially as fruitful as major cryptos like Cardano (ADA) and Ripple (XRP)? – ANI News

ANI | updated: May 24, 2022 10:02 IS New Delhi [India], May 24 (ANI/ATK):...

By wpadminsonic164
Bitcoin unter $50K! Kommt jetzt der BÄRENMARKT? Evergrande Zahlungsausfall! | Crypto News Videos

Bitcoin unter $50K! Kommt jetzt der BÄRENMARKT? Evergrande Zahlungsausfall! | Crypto News

NOCH FRAGEN? Schreib ein Kommentar und starte eine Diskussion! ABONNIEREN! Abonnier jetzt um nichts...

By wpadminsonic164
Prime 10 Altcoins to Watch Carefully in 2022 for Good Returns – Analytics Perception Stellar

Prime 10 Altcoins to Watch Carefully in 2022 for Good Returns – Analytics Perception

by Satavisa Pati January 1, 2022 You can invest in these top 10 altcoins...

By wpadminsonic164
Dogecoin: A very good entry set off for DOGE bulls could be discovered at… – AMBCrypto Information Dogecoin

Dogecoin: A very good entry set off for DOGE bulls could be discovered at… – AMBCrypto Information

Disclaimer: The findings of the following analysis are the sole opinions of the writer...

By wpadminsonic164
Polkadot

Top 10 Cryptocurrencies With a Better Future Than Bitcoin – hackernoon.com

Cryptocurrencies gaining popularity due to their ability to provide smooth transaction payments in a...

By wpadminsonic164
‘Night Sky’ Ending Explained and All Your Questions Answered – CNET Stellar

‘Night Sky’ Ending Explained and All Your Questions Answered – CNET

Prime Videos night sky might not be the most high-octane of sci-fi thrillers, but...

By wpadminsonic164
Binance stops Luna and UST exchanging following implosion – TechCrunch Binance

Binance stops Luna and UST exchanging following implosion – TechCrunch

Binance, the world's largest cryptocurrency exchange, has halted the trading of Terraform Labs' Terra...

By wpadminsonic164
Cardano

Ethereum, Ripple, Binance Coin, Cardano, and Polygon – Cardano Feed

This week, we take a closer look at Ethereum, Ripple, Binance Coin, Cardano, and...

By wpadminsonic164